As Dr. Watson, David Sweeney, left, plays Sherlock Holmes’ (played by Frank Jagdognik) sidekick in Coaster Theatre Playhouse’s ‘Baskerville’ production.

He once was a frenetic Roman slave, a grumpy old man and a robust Irish cop — each at a different point in his life.

Within 20 years, David Sweeney has played at least 60 roles at the Coaster Theatre Playhouse. But offstage, he takes on a different role: pastor of Seaside Episcopal Church.

Sweeney is comfortable wearing costumes, performing onstage Friday and Saturday nights, then donning religious vestments and leading worship on Sunday mornings.

“I’m able to maintain a separation between the two worlds,” Sweeney said. “But it’s still me. At some level, the character is coming out of the same person as the fellow in the pulpit on Sunday morning.”

Sweeney in 'A Christmas Carol'

David Sweeney played Bob Cratchit in the Coaster Theatre Playhouse’s production of ‘A Christmas Carol: The Musical’ in 2017.

As a child, Sweeney participated in middle school and high school plays in McHenry, Illinois. At Northwestern University, he earned a degree in speech education — combining theater, public speaking and interpretation of literature. After ordination, he acted in community theater in North Carolina and on the southern Oregon Coast, where he served at churches in Port Orford and Bandon.

Because his move to Seaside brought him to the area where his father grew up, Sweeney was naturally drawn to Coaster Theatre, he said.

Playing the part

Sweeney enjoys creating various characters.

“I’m not a skilled writer of fiction, and I’m not a particularly adept playwright, so (I like) the interpretive side of it as an actor, making choices with the help of a director and cast mates,” Sweeney said. “It’s fun. It’s a challenge.”

Sweeney working as a pastor

David Sweeney’s full-time role is as pastor of the Seaside Episcopal Church. Many in his congregation attend his performances at the Coaster Theatre Playhouse.

The challenge comes in finding his character’s personality and significant moments in the story. Sweeney doesn’t follow method acting but he uses experiences from his life to develop his characters.

Those characters included Rooster, a scam artist in “Annie,” Dr. Watson in “Baskerville” and the comedic Hystereum, a Roman slave in “A Funny Thing Happened On the Way to the Forum,” one of his favorite roles. Sweeney will reprise his role as Bob Cratchit, Scrooge’s assistant, in the Coaster’s Dickens Play Project, to be offered on Zoom Dec. 20, 22 and 24.

“He’s a very talented actor. He’s just a natural,” said Patrick Lathrop, the theater’s executive director. “He can play all sorts of different characters. He can be a gnarly, snarly character and he can be sweet as pie. He’s very good with accents and hearing the rhythms of various speech patterns. He’s a delight to work with.”

But one role Sweeney doesn’t see himself playing is Tevye, the father in “Fiddler on the Roof.” He decided that during an audition several years ago.

“The mix of things that Tevye embodies I didn’t see myself doing,” Sweeney said, referring to Tevye’s abrupt angry outbursts. “I don’t tend to be an angry person ... and that would have been difficult to dredge up.”

From playhouse to pastor


Actors Cathey Ryan, left, and Katherine Lacaze flank David Sweeney in a scene from ‘Annie’ in 2019.

Sweeney’s theater and pastoral roles overlap at times.

“I’m sure sometimes I preach things in my sermons to some extent based on my experiences at the Coaster,” he said. “Anything in your life can become gist for the mill. But I’m not sure how much each influences the other.”

Many in Sweeney’s congregation attend his theatrical performances.

“We did ‘Enchanted April,’ and there’s a moment that is sort of startling to people,” Sweeney said. “I saw somebody about a week after she had seen it, and she looked at me with this interesting, intent look and said, ‘Good play.’ ... I think one of the reasons the congregation enjoys that I do this is to see me in different ways. Different shows bring out different flecks in me.”

Recommended for you

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.